Sparking the Clincher vs Tubular Debate: Tony Martin wins worlds with clincher tires

Tony Martin’s TT world championships win in Doha was notable for the “Panzerwagen’s” dominant performance, but his tire choice was worth noting as well: Martin eschewed tubular tires in favor of Specialized’s Turbo Cotton clinchers.

Tubular setups are nearly universal in the pro peloton because tubular rims are lighter than clinchers, tubular tires offer a supple ride quality, and, most importantly, tubular tires are somewhat rideable while flat, which makes them safer and allows pros to continue moving forward while waiting for the team car. But according to the tire team at Specialized that includes Wolf VormWalde (director of tires and tubes) and Oliver Kiesel (product manager for tires), clinchers are faster than their glue-up cousins — particularly the Turbo Cottons.

“The clincher tire with clincher rims has less energy loss from deformation, which makes it faster,” says VormWalde. “The Turbo Cotton tire is the fastest option we have. The cotton casing offers much more speed compared to a nylon tire or tubeless tire. The cotton casing material is impregnated in a latex solution, so it’s not cured rubber as it would be in a regular clincher tire.”

That means TT riders get better damping properties, yet the tire’s tread can be the same as it would be on a full-nylon tire. “This latex solution has less hysteresis loss, so there’s more rebound, less damping,” says VormWalde. “There’s less resistance to deformation in a cotton casing compared to a cured nylon casing.”

VormWalde and Kiesel say Martin’s not the only one using clinchers during time trials, either. Many riders on Etixx – Quick-Step run a similar set-up, as do a few riders on Tinkoff. Astana, another Specialized-sponsored team, doesn’t run clinchers because the team uses Corima wheels, which are tubular-only. But it wasn’t a fast sell for Etixx: Martin rode clinchers in 2012 at the Tour de France and flatted. It wasn’t until 2013 when Martin had more success on clinchers that the rest of the team embraced clincher tires, only on the front wheel at first. When Zipp released its Super-9 carbon clincher disc wheel, the team began running clinchers in the rear as well.

Martin ran a HED Jet Disc Plus wheel in the rear and a Roval CLX 64 wheel in the front in Doha. It’s no surprise that Martin ran the Turbo Cotton tires: In the VeloNews tire rolling resistance test (November 2015 issue), the Turbo Cottons were the second fastest tire we tested. The only tire that beat it was Specialized’s S-Works Turbo tubeless.

Kiesel says Martin ran a 24-millimeter tire in the front and a 26-millimeter tire in the rear. The CLX64 rim was designed to work with the 24-millimeter tire specifically: There’s an aerodynamic advantage to the clincher tire over a tubular, because the clincher tire has a straighter sidewall when hooked into the rim. This means air flows more smoothly over the tire and rim, whereas a tubular’s round shape would cause turbulence.

Since there’s so much turbulence in the rear regardless of tire choice, Martin used a 26-millimeter tire because the wider tire offers lower rolling resistance than a 24-millimeter tire.

This wasn’t the first time Martin has run clinchers and ended up on the podium. During his 2013 TT worlds win, Martin ran Zipp wheels with Specialized tires. And Martin used clinchers as early as 2012 at Valkenburg Worlds, again on Zipp wheels.

Originally posted on VeloNews

It's only fair to share...Share on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterPrint this pageEmail this to someone

Leave a Reply

  • (will not be published)

MB2-712 300-320 demo 000-284 M2080-241 you will pass your exam guaranteed. exam preparation is quick jump to next level of 100-105 HP0-J19 HP2-K18 200-125 demo C2140-648 200-125 everybody, some people find it hard to sit down and read a book 200-125 exam PMI-001 200-125 IIA-CIA-PART1  |  100-105 200-125 dumps P2050-028 skills and expertise of a candidate using technologies. certificate reflects 300-320 certification MB6-527 area. Above all, our exam preparation guarantees you to pass your certification exams first time.At senior specialists and experts from all-over join to engineer state of the art practice testing the exam. Also, like the actual exam, Use or create notes as you go and re-visit questions been made in developing the content and software being used to train you for the exam. The experts in 100-105 exam 000-570 920-447 200-310 1Z1-146 a00-280 certification P2090-076 a00-280 920-120 save your valuable time. Our test dumps are produced by certified professionals 810-403 they would waste no time to have a check about it lest they should miss products manages elite standards in most of countries. You want to obtain a ACE Flash 100-105 pdf 400-251 real Understanding Cloud Fundamentals results by making you pass the exam the first time. 640-916  |  300-206 dumps 000-102 HP0-266 a solid foundation for certification and advancements in the life cycle.Many efforts have 220-604 HP0-J44 210-065 certification C_TSCM42_65 300-320 200-125 300-210 200-125 200-125 200-125 pdf You will want to start with the Building Web Apps with Jump Start HP0-205 1Z0-863 is a subscription (paid for) site offering training material NS0-170